1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 <2012> 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 | Index | 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 <2012> 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 |
<== Date ==> | <== Thread ==> |
---|
Subject: | RE: Epics gateway writeNotify issue |
From: | "Hill, Jeffrey O" <[email protected]> |
To: | "Hill, Jeffrey O" <[email protected]>, Provenzano Matteo <[email protected]>, "[email protected]" <[email protected]> |
Date: | Thu, 1 Mar 2012 18:36:03 +0000 |
Considering this matter further, the situation is somewhat more complex than it initially appeared. To completely fix the problem there will need to be two changes as follows. 1) casChannel::writeNotify should call
casChannel::write 2) We need also a new class casChannelDefault which forwards all of its virtual function directly to the
casPV interface. A casChannelDefault object shall be created only when the user doesn't implement a factory for the
casChannel interface in casPV. https://bugs.launchpad.net/epics-base/+bug/944188 From: [email protected]
[mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Hill, Jeffrey O Hi Matteo, Executive Summary: ================= I believe that you have found a bug. There are at least four permutations using these abbreviations new gateway (NGW),
old gateway (OGW), new CAS server library (NCAS), and old CAS server library (OCAS). {NGW, NCAS} (no bug) {OGW, NCAS} (bug, probably your situation, and bad old behavior not updating clients when write notify is in progress) {NGW, OCAS} (probably no bug, but bad old behavior not updating clients when write notify is in progress) {OGW, OCAS} (no bug) I created bug entry 944188, and you could also easily patch this issue yourself, but I recommend instead that you upgrade
to the latest version of the gateway (which will also resolve your issue and fix the old gateway behavior wrt write notify). To verify that you have the older version of the gateway check to see if it is implementing the writeNotify virtual function. Detailed explanation: ================= First some background info. When inspecting casdef.h (defining the interface between the server and services) one can see two interfaces casPV and
casChannel. Both of them have a similar virtual functions for implementing read, write, and writeNotify etc in the service. The casPV interface was first and it can be used when the PV is client agnostic in the service (its behavior does not change depending
on what client is attached). In contrast, the casChannel interface was added later for services which need to implement a PV that has a behavior which is different depending on what client is attached, or for implementing behavior that requires client specific
state variables. To maintain backwards compatibility the base class casChannel forwards requests such as read, write, or writeNotify to the interface in casPV. This happens when the service does not implement a factory for casChannel derived objects. Furthermore, in the original casPV interface there was only a “write” interface. Sometime back we discovered that it
was difficult to have a robust implementation of the gateway if the gateway was unable to determine if the CA request was a put, or a put notify. Therefore, a new writeNotify interface was added so that the gateway could be improved wrt put notify requests
(as I recall the old gateway would stop updating its clients when a put notify request was pending). Of course to maintain backwards compatibility the writeNotify interface calls the write interface if the service doesn’t implement writeNotify. Ok now about resolving your issue. I believe that casChannel::writeNotify is forwarding to casPV::writeNotify. This is a bug. To maintain strict backwards
compatibility casChannel::writeNotify should call casChannel::write. Jeff From:
[email protected] [mailto:[email protected]]
On Behalf Of Provenzano Matteo Hello everybody, I recompiled the epics gateway with the base.3.14.12. Now if I try to execute a writeNotify I always get the following error in the log file: Virtual gateVcData::write called for <channel name> This is an error! I searched for the source of this error and I found it in the file gateVc.cc (gateway/): // This is the virtual write function defined in casPV. It should no // longer be called if casChannel::write is implemented. caStatus gateVcData::write(const casCtx& ctx, const gdd& dd) { fprintf(stderr,"Virtual gateVcData::write called for %s.\n" " This is an error!\n",name()); return S_casApp_noSupport; } This function is actually called by this piece of code in casPV.cc (which is in
epics base/): // // casPV::writeNotify() // caStatus casPV :: writeNotify ( const casCtx & ctx, const gdd & val ) { // plumbed this way to preserve backwards // compatibility with the old interface which // did not include a writeNotify interface return this->write ( ctx, val ); } With the epics base.3.14.8 there was no problem. Has anyone idea how to solve this problem? Thank you for your help, Cheers, Matteo |