Re: cross-compiling v7.0.7

["Johnson, Andrew N. via Tech-talk" <tech-talk at aps.anl.gov>]

Most of that looks fine, but could you try unsetting your EPICS_BASE environment variable and see whether that makes a difference?

I can't replicate your symptoms when I try setting it myself, but I suspect it's likely to be related to that somehow. I haven't tried setting it in my .bashrc or .profile, I don't see how that could make a difference but it might. Were does your environment variable get set?

- Andrew

On 6/15/23 2:27 PM, Pierrick M Hanlet wrote:

Hi Andrew,
In base/configure/ I modify:
- CONFIG_SITE to define CROSS_COMPILER_TARGET_ARCHS and 
CROSS_COMPILER_HOST_ARCHS.
- CONFIG_COMMON to add USR_CXXFLAGS += -std=c++11

INSTALL_LOCATION remains commented out in CONFIG_SITE and I don't set it 
anywhere else.

In base/configure/os/ I have additional files (most are unmodified):
CONFIG.Common.target-arch
CONFIG.linux-x86_64.target-arch
CONFIG_SITE.Common.target-arch
CONFIG_SITE.linux-x86_64.target-arch

where target-arch matches one in the list from CROSS_COMPILER_TARGET_ARCHS.
Of these, I modify CONFIG_SITE.Common.target-arch to point to the 
cross-compiled
libraries, etc.

Yes, I have the EPICS_BASE set as an environment variable.  This allows 
me to test my
build in my own area before pushing to a production build in our CI/CD 
pipeline.

I don't use any command line flags with make apart from -s most of the 
time, though
not at the moment until this is sorted.
Cheers,
Pierrick


On 6/15/23 14:05, Andrew Johnson wrote:

Hi,

There is something unexpected in your environment then because the 
file should be created properly — it is when everyone else runs 
'make', and I'd like to work out what's different in your case; you 
shouldn't have to resort to creating it manually, or to replacing the 
RULES_MODULES file.

Do you happen to have an environment variable 'EPICS_BASE' set? Are 
you providing any additional command-line parameters when you run 
make? Do you have any files or a 'configure' directory in the parent 
directory of where Base is installed? Do you set INSTALL_LOCATION in 
any configure files?

- Andrew


On 6/15/23 1:56 PM, Pierrick M Hanlet via Tech-talk wrote:

Greetings Andrew,
Oddly, even "make clean" creates the new file, so it's a bit of a
nuisance; I have to have one
terminal to run make and another one to update (copy a working version
of the RELEASE.linux-x86_64.local
file) after the build has started.

Interestingly, the v7.0.5 also has a RELEASE.linux-x86_64.local with
"EPICS_BASE = ", but
that did not adversely affect the build.

Note that we have no special build locations.

I'm running a test now, and it appears that if I use the v7.0.5
./configure/RULES_MODULES,
everything works as before.
Cheers,
Pierrick


On 6/15/23 10:49, Andrew Johnson via Tech-talk wrote:

Hi Pierrick,

On 6/15/23 6:07 AM, Pierrick M Hanlet via Tech-talk wrote:

Something broke, or I missed new instructions in building the modules in
v7.0.7 for cross-compiled platforms.
I'm building for several platforms.  The host build is fine, but when
the cross-compiled platforms start building
a new RELEASE.linux-x86_64.local is created with "EPICS_BASE = ", i.e.
empty.  I did not experience this with
v7.0.5.

Hopefully the fix should be to just delete that file and run 'make'
again in that directory, but if you have a more complex local build
process (e.g. if you're building on multiple host arch's) that might
need some modifications. How were you doing the cross-builds?

Getting the build rules right for generating the
modules/RELEASE.<host>.local file was tricky, and there were some
changes made to them between 7.0.5 and 7.0.7:

$ git log R7.0.5.. -- configure/RULES_MODULES
commit 098ee6c063c25c3b4483d7d5a0b6c8c6d8d17769
Author: Andrew Johnson<anj at anl.gov>
Date:   Sat Sep 3 10:59:26 2022 -0500

     Oops: Fix to RULES_MODULES

commit efc7cbaf7f93c1bc58f98b30b9d20a27bc0a7f91
Author: Andrew Johnson<anj at anl.gov>
Date:   Fri Sep 2 14:10:27 2022 -0500

     Build system fixes related to INSTALL_LOCATION

     * The build can't descend into external submodules when there is no
     configure/RULES_TOP file present in $(INSTALL_LOCATION).
     * Recreate modules/RELEASE.<host>.local if configure/CONFIG_SITE or
     configure/CONFIG_SITE.local have changed.
     * Move the distclean of modules/RELEASE.<host>.local to RULES_TOP
     * Several comment and white-space changes

commit 191ff137f17eecde9e836f0f9aeaec5eecb73b24
Author: Andrew Johnson<anj at anl.gov>
Date:   Wed Nov 24 21:58:32 2021 -0600

     configure: Use GNU Make's abspath instead of fullPathname.pl

     Add new INSTALL_ABSOLUTE variable, remove duplicates.

There are some comments at the top of the RULES_MODULES file but they
were mostly intended for other applications that want to adopt the
submodules scheme (the motor record uses it too).

- Andrew
-- 
Complexity is free, it's Simplicity that takes work.

-- 
Complexity is free, it's Simplicity that takes work.

-- 
Complexity is free, it's Simplicity that takes work.