Experimental Physics and
Industrial Control System

Andrew Johnson via Core-talk <[email protected]> · Tue, 27 Aug 2019 16:49:38 -0000

Public bug reported:

>From Benjamin Franksen:

Here is a small self-contained database to reproduce this:

record(calcout,"input") {
    field(CALC,"A<4?A+1:A")
    field(INPA,"input")
    field(ODLY,"1")
    field(OUT,"input.A CA")
}
record(calcout,"output") {
    field(ODLY,"1.5")
    field(INPA,"input CPP")
    field(CALC,"A")
    field(TPRO,1)
}
record(calc,"check") {
    field(INPA,"input CPP")
    field(INPB,"output CPP")
    field(CALC,"A==B")
}

Processing "input" (caput input.PROC 1) starts the test. The "check"
record should eventually settle to 1 (but doesn't).

With 7.0.3 I get this output:

scanOnce: dbProcess of 'output' # initial CPP processing
scanOnce: dbProcess of 'output'
scanOnce: dbProcess of Active 'output' with RPRO=0
scanOnce: dbProcess of 'output'
scanOnce: dbProcess of Active 'output' with RPRO=0

Note how this says "with RPRO=0".

And camonitor says:

franksen@tiber: ~ > camonitor input output check
input                          <undefined> 0 UDF INVALID
output                         2019-08-27 16:02:16.106413 0
check                          2019-08-27 16:02:16.106617 1
input                          2019-08-27 16:02:26.498483 1
check                          2019-08-27 16:02:26.498721 0
input                          2019-08-27 16:02:27.493734 2
output                         2019-08-27 16:02:27.993908 1
input                          2019-08-27 16:02:28.489068 3
input                          2019-08-27 16:02:29.484350 4
output                         2019-08-27 16:02:29.984458 3

I think the difference in behavior between processing due to a CPP
input link versus processing due to a PP or CA output link is quite
surprising.

** Affects: epics-base
     Importance: Wishlist
         Status: Confirmed

** Affects: epics-base/7.0
     Importance: Wishlist
         Status: Confirmed

** Tags: codeathon

** Also affects: epics-base/7.0
   Importance: Wishlist
       Status: Confirmed

-- 
You received this bug notification because you are a member of EPICS
Core Developers, which is subscribed to EPICS Base.
Matching subscriptions: epics-core-list-subscription
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/1841634

Title:
  CP link triggers lost when record is async

Status in EPICS Base:
  Confirmed
Status in EPICS Base 7.0 series:
  Confirmed

Bug description:
  From Benjamin Franksen:

  Here is a small self-contained database to reproduce this:

  record(calcout,"input") {
      field(CALC,"A<4?A+1:A")
      field(INPA,"input")
      field(ODLY,"1")
      field(OUT,"input.A CA")
  }
  record(calcout,"output") {
      field(ODLY,"1.5")
      field(INPA,"input CPP")
      field(CALC,"A")
      field(TPRO,1)
  }
  record(calc,"check") {
      field(INPA,"input CPP")
      field(INPB,"output CPP")
      field(CALC,"A==B")
  }

  Processing "input" (caput input.PROC 1) starts the test. The "check"
  record should eventually settle to 1 (but doesn't).

  With 7.0.3 I get this output:

  scanOnce: dbProcess of 'output' # initial CPP processing
  scanOnce: dbProcess of 'output'
  scanOnce: dbProcess of Active 'output' with RPRO=0
  scanOnce: dbProcess of 'output'
  scanOnce: dbProcess of Active 'output' with RPRO=0

  Note how this says "with RPRO=0".

  And camonitor says:

  franksen@tiber: ~ > camonitor input output check
  input                          <undefined> 0 UDF INVALID
  output                         2019-08-27 16:02:16.106413 0
  check                          2019-08-27 16:02:16.106617 1
  input                          2019-08-27 16:02:26.498483 1
  check                          2019-08-27 16:02:26.498721 0
  input                          2019-08-27 16:02:27.493734 2
  output                         2019-08-27 16:02:27.993908 1
  input                          2019-08-27 16:02:28.489068 3
  input                          2019-08-27 16:02:29.484350 4
  output                         2019-08-27 16:02:29.984458 3

  I think the difference in behavior between processing due to a CPP
  input link versus processing due to a PP or CA output link is quite
  surprising.

To manage notifications about this bug go to:
https://bugs.launchpad.net/epics-base/+bug/1841634/+subscriptions

Experimental Physics and Industrial Control System

Experimental Physics and
Industrial Control System